Omega Protein, a Canadian-owned outfit, is vacuuming menhaden from the Chesapeake Bay, gutting the food chain for fish, birds, and local livelihoods. Their industrial overfishing is a slow-motion disaster, yet Virginia’s regulators seem asleep at the wheel. What’s really going on here?
Overfishing’s Toll on the Bay
Menhaden are the backbone of the Chesapeake Bay’s ecosystem, feeding striped bass, ospreys, and humpback whales. Omega Protein, headquartered in Reedville, Virginia, but owned by Canada’s Cooke Inc., harvests over 70% of the U.S. East Coast’s menhaden, turning them into fish oil, pet food, and fertilizer. In 2019, they blew past the Bay’s 51,000-metric-ton harvest cap by 33%, risking a federal fishery shutdown. Despite the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) raising quotas in 2023, citing healthy coastwide stocks, local depletion concerns persist due to Omega’s massive hauls.
Environmental Violations in Virginia
Omega’s track record is a mess. Since 2008, they’ve racked up Clean Water Act violations, including a $7.5 million fine in 2013 for dumping fish waste and oily wastewater into the Bay. In 2021, a net tear spilled 400,000 dead menhaden into Hampton Roads, polluting beaches and killing potential food for wildlife. Thirteen such spills have occurred since 2018, despite Omega’s claims of “rare” incidents. These disasters choke oxygen from waters, creating dead zones that harm crabs, oysters, and fish.
Overfishing Issues in Other States
Omega’s profit-driven overfishing isn’t just a Virginia problem. In Louisiana, their Gulf menhaden operations faced scrutiny for environmental violations. In 2014 and 2016, Omega pleaded guilty to Clean Water Act breaches at their Abbeville plant, dumping pollutants into Vermilion Bay, a critical habitat for shrimp and fish. Fines reached $1.5 million, but locals reported declining baitfish availability, impacting recreational fishing and pelican populations. Mississippi’s conservationists, including the Sierra Club, opposed Omega’s 2017 bid for Marine Stewardship Council certification, arguing their Gulf harvests depleted menhaden needed by speckled trout and redfish. New Jersey, New York, and Maryland banned reduction fishing within 3 miles of their coasts, citing ecosystem damage, yet Omega’s Virginia operations face no such state-water ban, amplifying their regional impact.
Profit Over Wildlife
Omega’s omega-3 products fuel a $4.45 billion market, driven by demand for supplements and aquaculture feed. To meet profit deadlines, they’ve skirted regulations. In 2010, Omega falsified environmental compliance to secure a $10 million federal loan, paying a $1 million settlement in 2019. Their refusal to share catch data with scientists hampers studies on menhaden’s ecological role, while osprey nesting failures and starving striped bass signal a collapsing food web. Meanwhile, Cooke Inc. exports menhaden for salmon feed, prioritizing global markets over local ecosystems.
Virginia’s Regulatory Failure
Omega Protein claims to follow sustainable practices, yet their actions tell a different story. Their refusal to share catch data with scientists hinders research on menhaden’s role in the Bay’s ecosystem. Consequently, osprey nesting failures and declining fish populations signal a broader ecological crisis. Therefore, Omega’s new spill response vessel, introduced in 2023, is a step, but many argue it’s too little, too late.
What can be done to balance economic interests with the Chesapeake Bay’s ecological health, and why hasn’t Virginia acted decisively to protect this vital resource?
Like this article?
☕️ Please buy me a coffee: https://buymeacoffee.com/criordan
👉 Follow me on X: @CRiordan2024
Click HERE to read more from Clara Dorrian.
